What makes me anti-national traitor

     Today I received an old forwarded message via whatsapp saying Indian National Anthem was awarded the best National Anthem of the world by UNESCO. The interaction that ensued thereof made me think where I stand in my communication skills and where India has reached in terms of patriotism and nationalism. The conversation is given below, with my friend’s name changed to 'Real Indian' as I was portrayed the antinational by him.

biNxWiz: V dont need a reason 2 b proud of India. If so we'l hate India for many other reasons, jus like singing glory to our cricketers wen they win and throwing stones when they lose. The message about National anthem is a fake one. Let's not get carried away with lies. Let us love our nation as it is, no matter how great or how worse it is.

Real Indian: Binny do u hate india?? Let us know y….

Real Indian: You can share ur feelings to hate india.  There is nothing wrong

biNxWiz: I wud like 2 know on wat context u say i hate India. Wen u say i hate India, which i dunno, u shud tel me. I'm afraid u dint understand wat i'm telling, or i failed in my communication

Real Indian: U said above national anthem.  Even I m too not sure whether that is correct information

Real Indian: If so.. then u have many reasons to hate india

Real Indian: This msg been forwarding since long back

Real Indian: I don't think we can react on such msg..

Real Indian: In my opinion. These kind of msg been forwarding daily. .

Real Indian: U have no reason to react like u hate india for many reasons

biNxWiz: That message is a fake one. I do a search before i believe in wat others say. Wen i received the same message frm my aunt i searched and found it was wrong

Real Indian: Yes I didn't said its correct. .cos every one don't know the truth. .

Real Indian: Like this der r many fake msgs every day

Real Indian: But do u have any specific reason to hate india

biNxWiz: It's not abt reacting. If someone says something wrong should we let them believ in it?

Real Indian: No need to believe. .for that u replied u have reason to hate

Real Indian: India is a big country der r many good n bad thing. . Some things Favor to some ppl n not for some ppl.

biNxWiz: I never said i hate India. I was taught 2 lov others, even my enemeys and how can I hate India? Have i ever hated u, tho i'm frm Kerala? I still dunno which part f India u belong, n i never bothered 2 find out, cus i lov u as u r. On wat basis r u accusing me f hating India?

Real Indian: I don't think v can say I hate india

Real Indian: U said u have reason to hate

biNxWiz: That's the real problem India is facing now. One person say somthng, anothr person understand somthng else n it turns out 2 b a fight between Indians

Real Indian: I m not accusing anyone. . Some ppl forward msg as it is without thinking. .

biNxWiz: I'm sorry 2 say, as i said earlier, either u dint understand or my communication was wrong

Real Indian: That msg doesn't hurt anyone. .

Real Indian: It may b wrong info

Real Indian: U could have aware ppl that it's wrong msg

biNxWiz: V r educated enough 2 find the truth rather than believing in lies

Real Indian: Yes

biNxWiz: Hav u evr thought that such fakes can turn a nation upside down? Beyond that, if v spread such lies who wud believ in the truth v say?

Real Indian: But I would like to suggest u.. I don't like if u think u have reason to hate india for silly msg

biNxWiz: C'mon boss, evn aftr sayng so much y r u not understanding?

Real Indian: Educated ppl like u and others never accept lies

Real Indian: This info may not be feel proud an Indian.. but don't u have any other reason to feel proud?

biNxWiz: First, pls clear ur mind of that misunderstanding abt my msg. I dint say i hate India. Please read that message few times. Stil if u dint under pls consult someone else 2 xplain it.

Real Indian: I read it..you said we ll hate for many reasons.

biNxWiz: Boss, didnt u read it starts with 'if so?'

Real Indian: Its not to hate india. . It's to hate to particular person or things..

biNxWiz: I'm sorry, i fail 2 make u understand wat i meant

Real Indian: Ppl are making mistakes and and troubling others. . For that reason v can't take India name

Real Indian: Don't take the name of India. .

Real Indian: This false information forwarded by humans. .

Real Indian: That's it I can said

biNxWiz: Ok fine boss, sorry 4 saying v shudnt lie n believ in lies.

Real Indian: I m not saying to belive lies

Real Indian: U react the person who spreading fake msg

biNxWiz: Ok, sorry for saying its fake

Real Indian: U didn't answer that don't u feel proud an Indian for any other reason?

Real Indian: I would like to hear that if u comments on such msgs that u also accept good part of India. .

Real Indian: Leave fake things and accept good things to feel proud. .

biNxWiz: The answer lies in wat i wrote 1st. No matter wat i say i am not able 2 communicate. So i give up

Real Indian: I need straight answer

Leave about that msg.. Don't u feel proud for any other reason ?

biNxWiz: No matter wat i say, when i'm not able 2 communicate, wat's the point? Abov all i can giv any answer, but how wil it make sense wen i can evn lie?

biNxWiz: Any1 can say anythng, but wat if he doesnt mean?

biNxWiz: The straight answer is there in wat i wrote 1st. Sorry, I dont kno how 2 make it clear

Real Indian: In india all types of ppls are there. . No need to worry about it. . Ppl who want dey love

Real Indian: Who doesn't no need to bother

Real Indian: India ll b always India. . Jai Hind

biNxWiz: :-)

      With that, as the conversation ended, I read my first comment again and again to find out where I mentioned that I hate India and where I belong as, me being an Indian, another person asks me not to use the name of India. Once, while discussing with one of my friends, he said that he didn’t read any of my messages and that he doesn't want to read any of them either. I wondered what was he chatting with me about until then. With today’s chat I realised that the so called patriots and nationalists are people who argue without even listening. I’m not sure if there is any future for thinking capability and debate in this country. Our future generation is going to be dumb in terms of common sense even if they will govern the world with their knowledge. But if I’m wrong in what I have written, then I don’t know when I will learn with such poor understanding capability of mine. 

      

     I would like to add a small story, which was written in Malayalam by someone and was shared through facebook. The story will deviate from the original a lot because it was some time back that I read it and I don’t recollect it well. The story goes like this: 

  

    Once there was a mother with two sons. One of the son will wake up everyday and go to the roof top and start shouting at the top of his voice: “I love my mother. She is the greatest one in this world and there is no other mother like her.” Every now and then he keeps shouting the same.

    The other son, who goes to work and take care of the mother, according to his brother, hates his mother because he doesn't say everyone that he loves her. One day all of a sudden there was a commotion with all the neighbours gathering in front of their house. The matter was that the mother started coughing and the ‘hating’ son said to the ‘loving’ son that she is coughing and we need to take her to doctor. The ‘loving’ son got enraged with this. He called all the neighbours and said: “See how much this fellow hates his mother. He says she has got cough. How can a son say such a bad thing about a mother? Shouldn’t he be beaten up for that?”

    The poor ‘hating’ son couldn’t do anything but keep quite with sadness in his heart. Days went by, and the mother’s situation was getting worse. Once again he approached his brother to take her to hospital. This time he gathered all his neighbours and wanted to kill him because it was too much for him to bear. The poor mother sat there coughing not able to understand what is going on. 

     I felt this story is apt in explaining what is happening in India of late. This chat with my friend made me feel as if it was with Arnab Goswami that I was doing it. Who is the one who loves and who is the one who hates. The wise and unwise will judge in their own way. Wish if wisdom prevail.

Related posts:

Mother please don't cry 
Who's an Indian

      

Choice of corrupt, currupt criminals and anarchy

          Had long been thinking of writing about the choice we have in 2014 elections. Time never let me, but the cash BJP gave on the election eve was the incentive, I believe, to write this. Since it's the first time, my mom didn't have any clue that the covers they handed over contained money.

          Coming back to the choice we have, as I tweeted some time back - choice given 2 votrs is like choice of chickn, mutton or fish 2 a Brahmin. Soon after I wrote that I realized that the Brahmin has a choice of rejecting it at the cost of his life. And NOTA option is what I felt the answer is.

          Thinking about the choices we have, though I feel Congress is far better than any other party that India can ever bank on, they are so corrupt and arrogant that they need to be taught a lesson. Delhi elections did that, but only to be left with the run-away bride. Looking at Congress, their ideologies are great. Most of their policies are good too. But what about the representatives. If we look at individuals, the party seems to bank on them blindly. They think India consists of only their party people. They seems to be blind to the fact that there are other people too. Giving seats to corrupt and criminals thinking they can win that seat is tragic. It will only make them lose as a whole. People of India are so fed up that they are ready to choose the greatest of evil than to vote for Congress no matter how suicidal it is.

          On the flip side, there is the party that was built up on blood, killing their own brothers and sisters in the name of patriotism, not knowing that they are just scapegoats of the greedy. I don't mean to say that other parties are free from criminal activities. But BJP as a party is built on hatred. The language the followers speak only proves it. The materials they distribute and the lies they propagate are all testimonies to it. When it comes to the policies, theirs used to be not much different from that of Congress. This time around it has changed a bit, but will only be for the worse. Capitalism seems to have got an upper hand. In the long run it will lead to great unrest in the country and, if followed, will lead to riots in future. We might see development, but at the cost of our nation's future.

        BJP this time has a very high chance of winning, taking into account the efforts and money that they have poured into PR agencies. India is a nation where people are driven by media to a large extent. People pay higher prices and buy cheap and poor quality goods if they are advertised. Branding plays a great role in our daily life. And BJP has done it so very well. They have managed to convince and eyewash even the educated by propagating the lies so well.

      BJP is a great threat to our nation for various reasons. First of all, it's hatred that they spread more than anything else. If we look at the nature, most of them are too arrogant. They give no value for justice. The language they use speaks of it all. Violence is part of their blood.

     Keeping away all these, when it comes to the political front, actually speaking BJP is no more. They are just at the mercy of Modi, which he himself has perfectly projected. I only pity on BJP in that matter that they are digging their own grave. What happened in Karnataka might be repeated, unless Modi can tactically eliminate how he did to the stalwarts who brought the party from scratch.

     Now that everyone is attracted to the bandwagon and jumping to the bubbly green side, when the expectations are not met, the turmoil will sweep away all that glitters. The party doesn't realize the danger that's in wait, for it's the greedy that is acquainting. Well, the writing is on the wall, and I need not say much about it. And what ever I say here will have no relevance until time reveals it. I only wish if our nation's future is not jeopardized.

     Few months back, there was a glitter of hope, who swept Delhi clean with the brooms. But what I felt in the later stages did happen and the pied piper, whom I initially thought would drive me to the polling booth for the first time in my life, just ran away. He had no proper agendas. He threw the broom in the dustbin. It looks like he has nothing else in mind other than anti-corruption. But that is not enough to run the administration. He has set his eyes on the PM chair. But how can he ever run a country if he couldn't manage a small place? When he openly proclaims that he is an anarchist, where will he lead us to?

     Then there is the regional parties who may form the third front and the communists. How much will the third front parties be able to do when it comes to managing our country? How will they be able to deal with other nations? Having Jayalalitha or Mamatha or Mulayam as our PM, I cannot even imagine what will be the state we will be in going forward, though it is not right to underestimate anyone.

    The communists on the other hand will lead our country to the stone age with their anti-capitalist and pro-labor mentality. They are just opposite to the BJP. If those who invest has no rights in their firms who would ever want to invest? It will lead to close down of most of the industries as it happened in Kerala. Under them I can only think of traveling in cycle ricks when our neighbors travel by metro.

        Coming to the end, thanks for the NOTA option. I guess I have a reason to vote this time. But I only hope and pray that the vote doesn't go to any party when I press the NOTA button.

AAP and the Pied Piper

           Long ago I had written 'A wake up call' stating the need for a change and that a new party should rise with those who had never been in politics before. I believe I weren't alone in thinking that way. There was a glimmer of hope when Anna Hazare started the movement against corruption. But soon he was pushed down from the heights where the very media took him to. Then there was this new kid in the block - Arvind Kejriwal. He had the guts to stand against the giant like David did to Goliath. With the broom stick he swept the streets of Delhi and showed Congress where they belong. But at end, when the war has been won, the hero seems to be throwing away the mantle and running away. The actions that followed have sown some serious thoughts in my mind. I doubt if people of Delhi have been royally fooled by this new bunch.

         I really wished if this party had the chance of governing the state because of their manifesto. But now I feel it was more like the manifestos any other party has ever released saying they'll do this and that for the people which will be followed by some more promises at the next election. We've seen enough of it. We were all fed up with the Congress due to corruption and it was then BJP rose with the banner 'party with a difference,' only to prove themselves to be worse than the other. Seems like history has repeated with a new difference.

          When I look at the outcome of the recent Delhi election, beyond the anger on Congress and the 'Modi' factor, what played a crucial role was the bait AAP threw. If the new party could eat into the vote share of Congress, sweeping it away like a whirlwind, wouldn't it be because of the promises AAP made? Free water and half-priced power - who wouldn't be tempted? AAP came out with the most unrealistic of promises as Arun Jaitley and Sheila Deekshit pointed out, if I'm not wrong. Of late I have a feeling that Kejriwal's intention was just to make sure that the government fall and not actually to form an ideal government. That is what I feel by his decision of not forming government even after getting so much of support.

          If Kejriwal had a real intention of giving a proper governance he should have taken the support, may it be of BJP or Congress, and formed the government. Saying that Congress and BJP are both corrupt and hence won't take their support is meaningless. If so he shouldn't have even contested and taken votes because he can never say that it was only those who are perfect in every way that voted for him. I don't think even he himself is perfect in everything, forget about those who voted. If his intention was right he should have headed the government and proved what he could do. When he says he is ready for another election is he not blowing away the money of those who donated with so much enthusiasm and above all the trust they put on him? Wouldn't it be a waste of public money more than anything else? Is he not running away from the responsibility that has been entrusted on him by the public?

          More than anything, the reason for the running away I feel is because he knows very well that the promises he made at the time of election is false and unrealistic. He would have released such a manifesto thinking he can drain away people from voting for those in power since they were so frustrated with corruption. But he never would have thought that his manifesto had the power to lure people into it like a magnet. Who would want to say no when promised with green pastures? Of course all these years every party did the same, but not to fool people to such an extent. And now that the unexpected happened, and people opted for him, he might be thinking that if he takes it up he'll have to fulfill the promises. Being a former IRS officer he should be knowing the realities at least to some extent .

         If Kejriwal really meant proper governance he should have staked claim and formed the government. In such an instance he need not succumb to the pressure of those who supports him. He can always do the right and show what it is meant to be clean governance. If such a government falls under pressure, doing what is right and just, people will surely stand by them. And if an election is held then they can come in  full power because people would have realized that they mean business. Their performance in the coming months would have given them a real base in the national arena as well as a run up to general elections. But if they are running away from doing so, then they are only cheating those who worked hard for them. I only wish if they take the mantle, prove me wrong in doubting them, and show the world what it means by GOVERNMENT.

(This material was actually posted in my other blog newvisionpolitics.blogspot.in. I'm posting it here too so that those who don't check that don't miss this)

NaMo namaha

NaMo, the third time Chief Minister when I write this, the man who is said to have changed the face of Gujarat, projected by media and many Indians as the future PM of India – is he the right one to lead India? Well, I’m not the right person to answer it, being a non-voter, but the general public of our nation. We need to wait and see what is in store.

When the world is getting ready to accept him as the future PM of our nation, especially with US and other nations reconsidering their stands on his visa, I have my own reservations about his candidature due to various reasons. Here I’m penning down few of the reasons.

The foremost reason why I find it hard to see him in the post is his dictatorship. India being a democratic nation it’ll be almost impossible for him to do anything at all. He may be able to reign in his state with his muscle power. But how can he ever manage India as a whole, especially with everyone wanting freedom from even their own people. The recent Telengana issue speaks a volume about it.

Those who are shouting from the top of their voices and those who wish very badly to see him in the post will one day curse themselves or at least will wish if that had never happened.  The Yeddiyurappa episode will only be just a precedent. His own people would want to get rid of him one day, the reason being every person wants to be on top.

When I say about danger, it is for various reasons. Bravery is good, which Modi is said to have, but wisdom is what is required to take us forward as a nation. Bravery will end up in destruction whereas wisdom will bring prosperity. Many bravehearts think he has the capability to take us for a war against Pakistan. But what about the consequences? Is patriotism all about hating other nations than loving our nation? We live at peace now. Won’t a war take away all that we have earned so far?

For that matter, I seriously doubt the bravery of the so called hero. Is he really a braveheart? What makes me doubtful about his bravery is his stance on the Gujarat riots. I have no idea what really happened. In this era of paid news we cannot trust anything. Yet in his case there are two sides to it. If he was brave to the likes of Hitler to mastermind the massacre isn’t he a coward who runs away without accepting it? On the other hand if he’s innocent isn’t he nothing but a false hero being carried on the shoulder by those who think he is the mastermind? Both ways he doesn’t seem to have any substance. He still lives in a shadow not able to confront it. Majority of them who supports him are in a dream world, blinded by emotions. This is evident from the words and deeds of almost all the Modi fans. They cannot digest the truth. I’ve realized this as few of my own friends, who knows me well, thinks of me as a different person than what I am, though I always make my stance clear. Though they are well educated they still cannot understand realities. If they cannot believe what I am telling about myself, how can they ever understand or believe other things?

When it comes to diplomacy, Modi will be an utter failure unless he changes himself. And if he changes then there will be no difference between him and others. I would like to point out the Kandahar incident. The self-proclaimed ‘patriots’ who always spoke about teaching a lesson had to bend their knees. I won’t call it as a failure because that’s what diplomacy is. A war is not the answer. But the Modi fans won’t understand that.

Speaking about changing himself, I feel he is a person who betrays his own people to fulfil his ambitions. It is evident from the Sadbhavana rallies and the makeover he’s trying to achieve. He may be able to fool most of them, but still he’ll be alienating himself from at least few of his own fans with an eye on the coveted post. Maybe few of them will realize it one day, but others will still remain blind as their fancies will remain as it is. But the reality will be that he would make them a fool who considers him as a hero.

Coming to Gujarat as the hub of development under him, I can only look at the hype with doubt, like the ‘Indian Rambo’ story. When we think of that development, I wonder how he could boast of it as it’s not too long ago that there was money pouring in from all corners of the world when an earthquake hit the state. Why is it that he couldn’t manage it himself? And why is it that he still takes funds from Centre, especially as it had been the centre of all industries, rich in natural resources and even the hub of diamonds since ages? 

Though media projects Gujarat to have been developed so much under him I never found Gujarat fare anywhere in national level when it comes to the available data. I did a search for the top most states in all available spheres, but couldn’t find Gujarat anywhere in the first three, especially in terms of literacy, health and even GDP. Of course there is no doubt that Gujarat has developed under him. But at the same time even those states that were considered backward not more than five years ago fares better than Gujarat. Being Chief Minister for three consecutive years won’t make him any better because there are others who had been in the post more than that.

Ruling a state is different from ruling a country. It’s like the frog in the well story. One needs proper understanding of how things happen. Otherwise it’ll be how I thought in my childhood that the best way to eliminate poverty is by printing money and distributing it to all.

Of course I don’t rule out that anyone can do who has a strong will, but not without patience to listen. To lead a country like India one needs to take into confidence at least a large section, though not everyone, considering the diverse culture and above all be really wise than brave.